ECTR Round Table in Moscow
The European Council on Tolerance and Reconciliation (ECTR) held a round table meeting in Moscow on October 25, 2011. Russian and international experts discussed issues of paramount importance connected with the current status, aspects and promotion of tolerance in Europe and in Russia. The experts also touched on such topics as the boundaries of tolerance, nuclear tolerance and secure tolerance in order to prevent a clash of civilisations.
The round table meeting was attended by Viatcheslav Moshe Kantor, ECTR Co-Chairman; Alexander Dynkin, Director at IMEMO of the Russian Academy of Sciences and fellow of the Russian Academy of Sciences; Vladimir Dvorkin, Professor and Principal Researcher at IMEMO, Russian Academy of Sciences;Mikhail Margelov, Chairman of the Foreign Affairs Committee of the Russian Council of the Federation; Leonid Slutsky, Senior Deputy Chairman of the Foreign Affairs Committee of the Russian State Duma;Yoram Dinstein,Professor Emeritus of International Law at Tel Aviv University; and Ireneusz Bil, ECTR Secretary General.
Emphasising the urgency of the notion of secure tolerance, ECTR Co-Chairman Viatcheslav Moshe Kantor noted that today the very notion of national security is vanishing. According to Kantor, “it is impossible to imagine the security of any country, regardless of its power and geographical position, if it limits its own perspective on the security only to its national borders. National security is giving way to global security. It is vital that the public be made more aware of the notion of tolerance. Tolerance must be limited primarily by security requirements.”
The ECTR’s initiative to establish a Centre for Tolerance and Security at a leading European university was also discussed. Following personal consultations with the President of the European Commission José Barroso and the European Commission, it was resolved to establish the Centre at the European University Institute in Florence (Italy).
Kantor said that “the Centre for Tolerance is perhaps one of the major humanitarian projects of the 21st century. This Centre must be the result of profound cooperation between the EU, Russia and the U.S., and cooperation is a prerequisite for its success. Our task is to create a bakery that will continually turn out buns called “laws and provisions on tolerance.” This will be a practical centre to prepare practical laws, regulations and rules of behaviour in every area where tolerance is important. Tolerance is important in every sphere of human activity – from nuclear deterrence, nuclear tolerance and boundaries to migration processes.”
One of the key issues discussed by the round table was the process of interethnic reconciliation. According to Kantor, “legitimising the reconciliation process establishes the grounds for development. If we can transfer this to a legitimate area, then any political leader will be able to say to his or her opponent: “Because of my political experience and my political doctrine, I personally cannot agree with the opponent, but following the letter of the law I must act accordingly.” We want to depersonalise the process of reconciliation. No politician should be responsible for it. This must be regulated by law.”
Closing the meeting, participants agreed to hold a large-scale conference on tolerance in Kazan (Russia) next year to mark the International Day of Tolerance.